Chapter 9 Reaction Chris Link
At
the start of last class, I asked a question about what peer review is. When I received
the answer, I was asked if I was confused about the peer review process. I was
in fact very confused because I hadn’t ever taken part in the peer review
process. When I got back from class I had every intention of looking up what
peer review was and how the process worked, but to be honest, I got extremely
lazy and just watched some Netflix instead. Luckily for me, Chapter 9 spelled
it out for me in a very clear and concise manner. Although I do say this every
blog post, I feel like this is the most important and helpful passage that I’ve
had to read for this class. Reading comments and other blog posts, I’ve noticed
that it’s a common trend to have been given little to no criticism in high
school peer review sessions. This seems like it wouldn’t help in the slightest
and it could potentially even have a negative effect on the paper. Seeing the
list of questions that can be used in the peer review process in Chapter 9
helped alleviate my worries that the peer review process would work the same
way. While this may be my first time being a participant in the peer review
process, I’m going to try my best to provide helpful criticism and feedback to
whoever I work with.
That was something the first part of chapter 9 did well, explaining what peer review actually is, rather than assuming we just know or will figure it out.
ReplyDelete